Since the Canadian government announced in December 2021 its intention to address the in Canada, civil society organizations and migrant representatives have called for Ottawa to deliver a broad and inclusive regularization program that gives status to undocumented people.
Authors
Delphine Nakache
Law Professor, L’Université d’Ottawa/University of Ottawa
Idil Atak
Professor, Lincoln Alexander School of Law, Toronto Metropolitan University
Jason Foster
Professor, Human Resources and Labour Relations, Athabasca University
Luin Goldring
Professor of Sociology, York University, Canada
that the current situation is mostly due to changes and gaps in immigration policies, and that the government has “an obligation to offer pathways to permanency for those who have been pushed to precarity.”
Undocumented migrants’ have been highlighted, along with the need to .
A lot has been written on , but less on what an effective program should look like. To do so requires a better understanding of those who live among us without status and without access to basic rights in Canada. Yet, as has shown, the composition of the undocumented migrant population in Canada is diverse and complex.
Examining migrant experiences
In 2018, our team received funding from Canada’s Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council to conduct a five-year project examining temporary migrants in Canada and their lived experiences in this country.
We sought to study the multitude of legal statuses held by temporary migrants and explore why and how migrants move in and out of authorized legal status.
The project involved field research conducted between October 2019 and June 2022 in four provinces: Alberta, British Columbia, Ontario and Québec. It focused on cities (Calgary, Edmonton, Toronto, Montréal and Vancouver) but also included smaller communities in all four provinces (Brooks, Nanaimo, Windsor and Québec City, respectively). The research team conducted interviews with 148 migrants with lived experiences of having temporary work authorization, losing status and attempting to gain or regain secure immigration status.
Migrant participants came from 35 countries and had diverse experiences. For example, some had entered Canada as temporary migrant workers while others had arrived as refugee claimants, visitors or international students. Additionally, 63 interviews were conducted with key stakeholders (for example, municipal civil servants, researchers, migrant representatives and “on-the-ground” practitioners such as legal and other service providers).
Two findings are worth noting.
Varying experiences
First, temporary migrants’ trajectories are far from being linear and predictable. In line with other , these trajectories involve multiple and time-consuming shifts in legal status, such as authorized to unauthorized, study permit to work permit, work permit to and open-work permit to employer-specific work permit, to name a few.
In their struggle to retain or regain their right to stay and work in Canada, 66 per cent of the migrant participants switched at least three times from one temporary migration status to another. This means there is no clear relationship between arriving in a specific immigration entrance category and losing status once in Canada.
Second, status changes – if successful – mainly involve changing from one temporary status to another and rarely lead to permanent residence; they can also lead to being without status.
At the time of the interviews, 80 per cent of migrant participants had no permanent status, while only 20 per cent had obtained permanent residency or citizenship. This means that many study participants had failed in their attempts to regularize their status, whether through an application for permanent residence or even another temporary category.
This reflects what and note about the very to permanent residency for people without status. This is important because precarious status is by employers.
Legal limbo
The government recently announced its regularization plans, but there’s no room for further delay. Regularization is urgently needed now to provide a concrete solution to the legal limbo currently experienced by the many people who have no status.
As our findings suggest, and as has been advocated by both and , are not the answer. Canada needs a regularization program that isn’t limited to a specific category or profile of temporary migrants. It should be straightforward and safe for all applicants by leading directly to permanent residence.
Temporary migrants will continue to lose status, and face heightened vulnerability, as long as the key components of migrant illegalization are not properly addressed.
Beyond regularization, it’s crucial that the federal government recognizes and addresses the many structural problems of the current migration system that result in migrants living and working in Canada without authorized immigration status.
These include, among others, , delays in immigration proceedings and the lack of legal aid for temporary migrants.
Listen to ‘Don’t Call Me Resilient’ podcast flashback episode:
The project mentioned in this article received funding from Canada’s Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (Delphine Nakache, Principal Investigator; Idil Atak, Luin Goldring, Jason Foster (Co-investigators). It benefited from the research and analysis of the following PhD students/co-researchers: Mylene Coderre, Giovanni Carranza, Maria Fernanda Mosquera Garcia and Zainab Mahmood.
.
